April 9, 2026

1 thought on “FAIR Conference Podcast #83 – Daniel C. Peterson, “Brigham Young and Slavery”

  1. It was a good presentation, but I often feel like we spend so much time trying to defend Brigham Young and other 19th and 20th century prophets’ and apostles’ honor that we fail to really grapple with the real issue. Why in the 19th century was slavery even an issue that Christian nations were wrestling with? I think Ben Spackman captures the real essence of the issue in his Gospel Doctrine/Come Follow Me essay on Philemon. The essay pivots around what I think is one of the most compelling questions anyone has every asked about a difficult topic like slavery. “The problem … is that scripture fails to live up to a standard we see as ethically and morally cut-and-dried, and presumably eternal… What model of scripture, revelation, and prophets allows “God’s word,” God’s prophets, and Jesus himself to do or allow something so… inhuman?”

    I recognize that Dr. Peterson’s presentation is largely motivated by Reeve, Rich, and Carruth’s book which isn’t delving deep into Biblical history trying to understand how slavery became a thing among the Israelites. It seems to me that this is the underlying issue that makes slavery such a difficult issue for believers.

Comments are closed.